Regulatory law firms ranking

International law firms are leaders in energy sector

Ranking 2017-04-05
CMS and Dentons took the lead in our ranking.* In the coming year, the energy industry practices will cover energy market regulation and the law on windmills.



Key points

Contacts with regulators, licenses, contracts and RES auctions. Law firms represent business in contacts with regulators, such as the URE regulator and UOKiK, and ministries, primarily with MinEnv. They assist in obtaining licenses for the production, distribution and trading in energy, heat and gas, as well as for prospecting and mining for minerals. In addition, energy lawyers negotiate contracts for the purchase of gas, oil and coal. Despite the collapse in the wind farm industry last year, they helped green energy producers prepare for the first RES auction in December, 2016.

In some cases they call on the help of other departments. For example, in case of energy companies mergers - their M&A departments assist, while in court proceedings and before the URE - their processing departments are called into action. Sometimes energy departments are also assisted by their offices’ corporate law teams, as in the ownership transformations in Polish mining, such as the formation of Polska Grupa Górnicza in 2016. This form of cooperation takes place first and foremost in large law firms (both international and domestic) that are sub-divided into departments.

A number of personnel changes. Michał Piekarski, the leader of the energy law practice at Baker McKenzie, moved to the firm from Polenerga, at the same time as Piotr Ciepiela moved from URE. Jakub Kasnowski, previously associated with Wierzbowski Eversheds Sutherland, joined Deloitte Legal. Marta Bryjak joined Linklaters after six years working with White&Case, while Piotr Manteuffel moved from ChanPM to EChW's energy department, headed by Anna Kucińska-Bar. In another move, Aleksander Jakowlew from the Gide office began working with Clifford Chance. 2016 also saw important promotions within energy teams: Piotr Ciołkowski of CMS became a partner and Paweł Puacz at Clifford - a counsellor.

Energy work is dominated by the big law firms. As last year, CMS was the leader in the rankings. Dentons, whose Warsaw and European energy and natural resources team is led by managing partner Arkadiusz Krasnodębski, moved up into the first group. Norton Rose and WKB held their second place, followed by Radzikowski, Szubielska and Partners from the third group. Its lawyers formerly made up the Warsaw office of Chadbourne & Parke, but after this foreign company withdrew from Poland they operate under their own names. Group three again includes DZP and Clifford Chance. The new law firms here are Weil, Squire Patton Boggs and Baker McKenzie.

Lawyers helped to create Polska Grupa Górnicza. DZP advised on transformations in the Polish mining industry, including the formation of PGG, which is the largest producer of hard coal in the EU. Dentons represented PSE in the cross-border cases related to the European CACM regulation on transfer capacity allocation and the management of limits. Clifford Chance lawyers in their turn assisted Katowicki Holding Węglowy in the sale of 100 per cent of shares in Katowice's Zakłady Energetyki Cieplnej to DK Energy Polska - a company owned by the French EDF group.

what's next

In 2017, the most important thing for the sector will be the publication of the final version of the law on the capacity market. The government's draft is intended to improve the financial situation of the owners of conventional power plants. Law firms will assist clients in interpreting the imprecise provisions of the law on windmills, which has left firms not knowing how much tax to pay for wind towers. They will also help them in adapting to the possible changes that the RES sector is facing, including the auction system. Revenues will also come from the ownership transformations in the mining industry and the complex process of merging PGG with KHW.

Robert Tomaszewski contributed to this analysis.

* The ranking includes law firms handling regulatory advice, related to public economic law enforced by regulators such as UOKiK, URE and KNF. On March 23, a gala was held to award diplomas to law firms. This is the first ranking of law firms in Poland taking into account qualitative data. The results are based on survey data collected by PI analysts among major companies in regulated sectors and the law firms themselves.

Write to author
Justyna Jawor
Fmr. Legal Affairs Analyst
Justyna Jawor
PI Alert

Polish government announces new restrictions

At a joint press conference, PM Mateusz Morawiecki and MinHea Łukasz Szumowski announced a ban on gatherings of more than two people (it does not concern family members). The government also limited reasons why people may leave their homes. It is only possible when it is absolutely necessary, which means that Poles can travel to and from work, for medical reasons, and to do their shopping. Furthermore, it will be allowed to walk a dog or to go for a walk. The Polish government limited the maximum number of passengers in public transport (only half of the seats can be taken, there should be at least one free seat between the passengers). New restrictions will apply from March 25th. Previous restrictions are still in force.

PI Alert

Government introduces state of epidemic

• "To prevent a further spread, limit it, implement adequate rules, also in quarantined areas, we are implementing today a state of epidemic," said Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki. In contrast with the state of epidemic danger, it allows for creating "zero zones" around a virus outbreak, which would make it possible to close entire cities. This means that by a decree signed by a voivode (or MinHea for all of Poland), could direct people, especially medical staff, to assist in battling an epidemic. The government also decided to extend the closure of schools through Easter (Easter holidays were to start on April 9) and raised penalties for breaking a quarantine from PLN 5,000 to PLN 30,000. However, the introduction of the state of epidemic does not mean a delay of the presidential election.

• President Andrzej Duda, in a televised address, announced that he would convene another National Security Council on Monday, March 23, to discuss the "crisis shield" plan announced by the cabinet. He also thanked the medical services and citizens involved in the fight against the virus and called on people to treat security rules seriously.

• The Sejm praesidium, which met today, discussed the way next week's session will be held. During this sitting, the MPs are to discuss the senate's amendments to the budget and the "crisis shield". The final decisions will be taken on Tuesday. According to our information, the sessions is planned for Friday, March 27. At today's meeting, the parties discussed two main scenarios for the sitting: spreading out the MPs throughout the Sejm building or a remote session.

• During a news conference, the prime minister said that the draft legislation introducing the "crisis shield" is nearly ready and is being finalised by MinDev. It includes around 50 amendments to various laws that would help companies and workers to get through the crisis caused by the coronavirus pandemic. According to our information, on Thursday night, MinDev received several dozen pages of amendments from various ministries. Over the weekend, MinDev wants to consult with social partners about the legislation. According to PMChanc head Michał Dworczyk the cabinet wants to pass the legislation by circulating it among the ministers. Dworczyk added additional changes could be introduced at the last minute.